After much trial and error. I came up with a design that can be replicated easily. That's the video above.
The Sorting Hats below are very hard to get right the first time. I made them over and over to get a few that looked descent. They are hard and labor intense. But I have created the above video for a much faster and simpler way to make them. Thanks again for all your interest. Please in joy.
Sorting Hat made of Caramel candy
Droobles (box of Caramel),
Bertie Botts Every Flavor Beans (Jelly Bellies),
Licorice Wands (black licorice candy),
All labels were specially created and designed myself.